Chris Powell's Flat Cap

Home » Opinion » Charlton Supporters Are Simply Not to Blame

Charlton Supporters Are Simply Not to Blame

It’s rather ironic that the man at the centre of one myth harmful to the pride of Charlton Athletic supporters has enhanced the weight behind another being seen as a truth.

For so often since our decline from the Premier League, we have had to defend ourselves against this notion that our impatience and greed pushed Alan Curbishley out of the club, and therefore means we only have ourselves to blame for the many subsequent periods of despair and crisis since.

True, there was frustration that qualification for European football could not be achieved, particularly with Curbishley’s side regularly finding themselves in promising positions as the season entered its final quarter. Those end-of-season slumps understandably creating a feeling that more could have been achieved during our time in the top flight.

But frustration, and a rather timid sort at that, was all that ever existed. Never were there any serious murmurings of displeasure against Charlton’s legendary boss of 15 years, let alone mass calls for him to be dismissed in the hope of reaching the next level.

In fact, as it was announced prior to the final home game of the 2005/06 season that Curbishley had made the decision to move on, tears left the 11-year-old eyes of your writer in a shocked and heart-broken Covered End. Tears leaving Curbishley’s eyes as he said goodbye following that 2-0 defeat to Blackburn, and his effort thanked by all at Old Trafford a week later. Supporters supportive and appreciative until the very end, unlike the perceived narrative might suggest.

Particularly disappointing, therefore, that Curbishley has seen it fit to question the supportive efforts of Charlton’s fans in recent weeks. It can be ascertained from his words on Football League Tonight on Saturday that he believes both the protests and the mood within The Valley have had a serious impact on the performances of the players. Protection for this regime, an excuse for the underperforming men in red, and an unfair accusation against supporters.

I’d like to think those beliefs are a result of genuine ignorance, especially given his suggestion that the protests should be postponed until the summer. A sign that he isn’t fully aware of the extent of the damage Roland Duchatelet and Katrien Meire have done, and continue to do. As such, I have no anger towards Curbs, only a sense of disappointment that he doesn’t seem to have an understanding of events at a club where his considered a legend.

But a true sense of frustration comes from the extent at which this belief we are not supporting the team has grown, both in recent weeks and following Curbishley’s comments. That we are contributing towards what appears to be an inevitable return to League One.

I won’t deny that there is evidence to support such views. There have been moments this season where supporters, in the midst of this bleak period, have let frustration and disappointment get the better of them.

Some will point to the numerous occasions where the team has been mocked or booed off the pitch, the incident which saw Morgan Fox substituted during the defeat to Bristol City to heckles and abuse, and the times where protests have occurred during a game.


But the atmosphere has only ever been anything less than supportive of those representing the Addicks once our efforts have not been suitably rewarded. Games always beginning with more support than a side occupying the relegation zone are arguably worthy of, and only replaced by angst once they underperform to a point of no return.

The most poisonous atmospheres this season coming when players have either not responded to support, or showed such a lack of quality and fight that frustration and anger is completely understandable. The FA Cup defeat to Colchester United a prime example, and there have been plenty of other examples this season where our support to begin with means we are completely blameless for the defeat that has followed.


Any booing that has occurred a justified show of disappointment at poor performances, and the mocking of individuals or the collective normally light-hearted. Celebrating a shot when already three goals down at Hull City probably the only way to avoid a complete breakdown, while there really wasn’t a need for Johann Berg Gudmundsson’s look of disgust as the Covered End found humour in a horribly wayward Reza Ghoochannejhad strike.

Of course, the Fox incident was a rare occasion where the extent of the anger shown was unjustified, and the reason why the suggestion we’re not supporting the team had grown before Curbishley added his thoughts.

But Fox, who deserves little personal blame for his struggles when it is Duchatelet’s system that has exposed him to such an environment he is not yet ready for, was merely an unfortunate victim of the general unrest that exists among supporters. It unreasonable to suggest that supporters should be robotic supporting machines while their club is in crisis, they occupy a relegation spot, and continue to perform dreadfully.


Regardless, I’m of the opinion that we as supporters can be proud of our efforts this season. I certainly don’t think we’ll reach the end of this campaign, regardless of what the end result is, and feel any sense of guilt in our actions whatsoever.

There is always going to be a degree of unhappiness in a situation like this one – the supporters of every other club in a relegation battle this season will have voiced their frustration on numerous occasions, and the club and players are the ones that need to shoulder the blame for creating a situation where such anger exists.

But each game has been treated as a fresh start, with disappointment from the previous encounter replaced by a chorus of support from the Covered End or a vocal away end. Players well backed in that horrendous run between the Colchester defeat and the draw against Blackburn, and arguably undeservedly so. Our persistence should be the focus, not our displays of anger in moments of disappointment.


For this idea that The Valley atmosphere is not what it should be is not a consequence of the Covered End losing its voice, supporters turning their back on their side, or insults replacing support. The reason the atmosphere has been damaged, as Curbishley believes, is because of numerous demoralising defeats, and the way the club is being run has produced anger and apathy.

It’s why the protests, not just in their goal to remove Duchatelet, are vitally important. A supporter spirit has been ignited, with the collective voice that wants this regime gone then followed by a collective voice that wants the side to achieve victory. Together in supporting the team, and together in not supporting the regime.


A show, too, that we as supporters have not given up. It would be easy to bury heads in the sand and hope it all goes away, but we have showed the same sort of persistence in our protesting as we have in our support.

Nor is protesting something that anyone wants to do. No one wants to have to effectively fight against their club, but it has reached a point where we are doing a job as supporters to protect and fight for the future of our club. We’re doing this because we care. Because we want Charlton to succeed, and can substantially prove that unlike this ownership.

Besides, this notion that protesting during the game is harming the team is, quite frankly, rubbish. If a professional footballer is more affected by a minute of holding up banners or standing up against the regime than numerous minutes of positive support, then they do not have the required character to be a professional football.


And it would seem that the players are appreciative of efforts anyway. Stephen Henderson’s quotes following Saturday’s draw with Cardiff very important:

“The fans have been great with us. Obviously we’re aware of the shenanigans at times but they have been great with us and that’s all we can ask. They’ve got to do what they’ve got do. As long as they support us, is all I ask.”

“I’d really like to thank them for their support.”

Confirmation, if it were needed, that we’re doing a mighty fine job of supporting the team, and not the regime. It is possible to protest, and provide the sort of support needed for the players to perform. We’re not creating a difficult atmosphere at all.


Opposition observers also commend our efforts, and appreciate our bewilderment. Important words from Phil Smith, writing for Wales Online:

“Though their support of the team was unwavering, particularly in the final ten minutes as they pushed for an unlikely winner, the sense of disillusionment in the Valley was unquestionable.

You could feel it in the SE7 streets around the stadium beforehand, and you could certainly feel it when they stood as one to demand Duchatelet sells the club.

They wore Pinocchio masks and stickers in protest, even printing beer mats to be used pubs near the ground.”


We’re doing a commendable job in these testing circumstances, supporting the team until their efforts mean disappointment and anger can only takeover, and providing hope and togetherness with the protesting efforts.

A job far greater than many connected to Charlton Athletic have done this season.

We simply are not to blame if this side does not collect the points it needs to survive.




  1. richard says:

    Nice post Kyle.

    On the Curbishley thing…I’m old enough to remember him playing for us. From the start we supporters had an uncomfortable relationship with him. Perhaps because he was seen as a West Ham man at heart.

    Personally I will always be enormously grateful to him for what he did for us. He was certainly the most influential and successful manager of my lifetime. However, even during those halcyon days of the Premiership he remained somewhat aloof and removed from us the fans, and while I was happy to let him be, others did judge him harshly for that, and in turn I think he judged us quite harshly in return.

    In his autobiography I was struck by how he felt unrecognised for his achievements. He was quite bitter about not getting the England job when it was given to Maclaren. I think he left because he thought he was worthy of managing a ‘big’ club. Sadly that never worked out for him and both his and our fortunes have suffered since he left. We will never know what would have happened if he had stayed, and been given the money that Dowie and Pardew were given. Perhaps he would have proved that he could push us onto the next level, or perhaps we were in fact the summit of his capabilities.

    Regardless of all that, what he said on Chanel 5 while uninsightful at best, were quite typical of his opinion of us, and that does make me sad, on many levels. I think if Curbs is honest with himself, he is sad too.

  2. Mark Jones says:

    An absolutely excellent summing up of where we are as supporters in the big mess that CAFC has become under the regime.

    The only times that I have witnessed the fans turning on the players have been as the result of an abject individual performance (of which there have sadly been a few this season…) or a communal loss of pride in wearing the shirt.

    I was disappointed to hear of Curbs views on the Football League show on Saturday – as he watches from the stand at Craven Cottage on Saturday and observes the performance out on the pitch (unless there’s a Rotherham-like resurrection!) he may come to realise what the demonstrations are all about and just how low the club that he successfully built up and led for so long has sunk under this despicable regime. He may also realise that there is not a minute to be wasted in trying to get Duchatelet to sell up and get the hell back to Belgium before he does irrepairable long-term damage to the club.
    We are already a long way down that road – whoever takes over the club will have to re-build the club from a mid-table first division situation at the very least which will take some years to achieve …. unless of course Sir Chris is available to weave his magic in the transfer market and can get rid of 16 dead-weights and bring in 16 players to get the club instantly out of the mire as he did just a few years ago.
    The clutching of straws continues – that’s what we have become as supporters of CAFC, a bunch of straw grabbers. Thanks for nothing Duchatelet.

    With regards to Curbs most Charlton supporters at the time were well and truly happy to just be in the Premier league and were happy to finish 4th from bottom, anything above that being an absolute bonus!
    There was a small minority of supporters who did question “where can the club go from here” or “why can’t we qualify for Europe….?” Seems laughable now from the position we are in at the moment – but I do remember at the time stating that those who question Curbs ability to manage the team should be careful for what they wish for as the damage caused by Curbs leaving was far more dangerous than just missing out on a European spot….
    I suspect that the small minority would join in the views of the majority in 2016 and say “I wonder if we would still be in the Premier League if Curbs had stayed on……?” Who knows, but one thing is for sure, if Curbs were still in charge at the Valley the club would be in a far better position than it is today.

  3. Steve says:

    Great post.
    I have to say though, I was in The Royal Oak before that game when news filtered through that Curbs was leaving at the end of the season. To my dismay, a big cheer went up. Honestly. Never a truer case of be careful what you wish for. I know it’s still just a minority but probably the same minority that boo acadamy players and sarcastically cheer others. Please no more chats of ‘we’ve had a shot’? If I was a player I know how I’d react.
    So fans fully to blame, no way but we’ve played our part in our downfall.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: